School of Biological and Molecular Sciences, Oxford Brookes
University, Gipsy Lane Campus, Oxford, OX3 0BP (L.S.A., I.B., L.A.K.)
and
Merck Sharp & Dohme Research Laboratories, Neuroscience Research
Centre, Terlings Park, Eastwick Road, Harlow, Essex, CM20 2QR (K.A.W.)
 |
Introduction |
The
GABAA receptor is a transmembrane protein complex
that forms an ion channel that is selectively permeable to chloride ions. The channel is directly gated by GABA, and the protein subunits that make up the receptor have specific binding sites for convulsants such as picrotoxin and TBPS, as well as barbiturates, benzodiazepines and the anesthetic steroids. Cloning of the GABAA
receptor subunit cDNAs has revealed considerable heterogeneity, with at
least six alpha, four beta, three
gamma, one delta and two rho subunits, which provides a molecular basis for multiple
GABAA receptor subtypes which distribute
throughout the brain (McKernan and Whiting, 1996
).
Organochlorine insecticides such as
-HCH or lindane also interact
with the GABAA receptor, inducing convulsions of
the Grand Mal type (Tussel et al., 1987
; Portig and Schnorr,
1988
) and inhibiting GABA-induced chloride flux in a wide range of
mammalian brain preparations (Abalis et al., 1986
;
Bloomquist et al., 1986
; Pomés et al.,
1994
) and in Xenopus oocytes expressing rat
GABAA receptors (Woodward et al.,
1992
). Studies showing that
-HCH displaces [35S]TBPS from its binding site in rat brain
membrane homogenates (Lawrence and Casida, 1984
; Llorens et
al., 1990
) suggest that this insecticide acts by interacting with
the picrotoxin site of the GABAA receptor. In
contrast, the
,
and
isomers of
-HCH have been reported to
have only weak effects or act as central nervous system depressants
(McNamara and Krup, 1948
). The site of action of these isomers in the
mammalian central nervous system has not been determined yet, although
studies, which show them to potentiate GABA-activated chloride channels
in Xenopus oocytes (Woodward et al., 1992
) and in
primary cultures of cortical (Pomés et al., 1994
) and
dorsal root ganglion neurons (Nagata and Narahashi, 1995
), indicate
that they interact with the GABAA receptor. Here we report studies of [35S]TBPS binding in
membrane homogenates of a mammalian clonal cell line expressing the
human
1
3
2S GABAA receptor subtype and
voltage-clamp recordings of human GABAA receptors
expressed in Xenopus oocytes, which suggests that
-HCH is
a partial inverse agonist of the picrotoxin site and that
-HCH
interacts with a site linked to the barbiturate locus of the
GABAA receptor.
 |
Methods |
Human GABAA receptor subunit cDNAs.
Complementary DNAs encoding human GABAA
1,
6,
3 and
2S receptor subunits have been described elsewhere
(Hadingham et al., 1993a
,b
, 1996
).
Electrophysiology.
To obtain oocytes, adult
Xenopus frogs were anesthetized by immersion for 30 to 45 min in a solution of 0.4% ethyl m-aminobenzoate (Tricaine),
and a small piece of ovary was removed through an incision in the
abdominal wall. Stage V and VI oocytes were isolated and the theca and
epithelial cell layer were removed mechanically with fine watchmaker
forceps. Follicle cells were removed by an 8-min treatment in Sigma
type IA collagenase (0.5 mg/ml) dissolved in MBS (88 mM NaCl, 1 mM KCl
10 mM HEPES, 0.82 mM MgSO4, 0.33 mM
Ca(NO3)2, 0.91 mM
CaCl2, 2.4 mM NaHCO3, pH
7.5). Oocyte nuclei were directly injected with 10 to 20 nl of sterile
buffer (88 mM NaCl, 1 mM KCl, 15 mM HEPES, pH 7.4) containing different
combinations of human GABAA subunit cDNAs
engineered into the expression vectors pcDM8 or pcDNAI/Amp. Oocytes
were incubated for 1 to 2 days in MBS supplemented with 2 mM sodium
pyruvate, 2 ml/l penicillin streptomycin solution (containing 100 U/ml
penicillin, 10 mg/ml streptomycin), and 50 mg/l gentamycin. For
recording, oocytes were placed in a 50-µl bath and perfused with MBS
at 4 to 6 ml/min. Cells were impaled with two 1 to 3 megohm
agarose-cushion electrodes containing 2 M KCl and were voltage-clamped
at
70 mV. Drugs were applied in the perfusate and GABA was applied
until the peak of the response, which for most of the oocytes was 30 sec or less. To measure potentiation by allosteric modulators a
submaximal concentration of 20% was chosen, which gave optimal
potentiation while remaining on the linear portion of the curve. To
measure inhibition of GABA responses an EC50
concentration was chosen, which gave a robust signal without the
run-down problems associated with continuous challenging with a maximum
concentration. After maximal response to GABA (3 mM), constant
responses to an EC20 or
EC50 concentration were obtained. An
EC20/50 concentration was
the concentration of agonist that produced 20% or 50% of the maximal
response for that agonist. At least 3 min were allowed between each
drug application to prevent desensitization. Concentration-response curves were fitted by use of GraFit (Erithacus software, from Sigma-Aldrich Ltd., Poole, Dorset, U.K.) to the equation:
f(x) = Bmax/[1 + (EC50/X)n],
where Bmax is the response at saturating
concentration of ligand; EC50, the concentration
of ligand producing a half-maximal response; X, the
concentration of ligand; and n, the Hill coefficient.
Arithmetic mean values were calculated from data obtained from a number
(n) of different cells. The statistical significance of
differences between mean values were assessed by Student's two-tailed
t tests, wherever appropriate.
GABAA receptor cell line.
Mouse
fibroblasts stably expressing the human
1
3
2
GABAA receptor were maintained as described
previously (Hadingham et al., 1992
). Semiconfluent cells
containing the human
1
3
2s GABAA receptor
were induced with 2 µM dexamethasone for 8 days to gain maximum
expression of the recombinant receptor.
[35S]TBPS binding assay in membranes of
induced mouse clonal cells.
Eight-day induced cells were washed
off culture flasks with phosphate-buffered saline (pH 7.4). Cells were
washed twice for 5 min at 200 × g, resuspended in 5 ml
of ice-cold 5 mM Tris citrate (pH 7.4) containing 1 mM
ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid, 1 mM phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride, 1 mM benzamidine hydrochloride, 1 mM leupeptin and 0.5 mM soybean
trypsin, pH 7.4. Cells were then broken up by probe sonication on ice,
for a total of 30 sec (three 10-sec bursts to prevent overheating). The
homogenate was centrifuged for 5 min to remove nuclear material
(200 × g; 4°C), and the supernatant was centrifuged
for 1 hr at 90,000 × g, at 4°C. The resulting pellet
was resuspended in 5 ml of 50 mM Tris citrate, pH 7.4, and quickly
frozen and thawed. The thawed homogenate was then incubated for 30 min
in 50 mM Tris citrate containing 0.01% Triton X-100 at 37°C. The
homogenate was then washed twice in 50 mM Tris citrate buffer, pH 7.4, by centrifugation at 90,000 × g for 1 hr. The final
pellet was resuspended in the required volume of 50 mM Tris citrate
buffer. Protein content was determined using a commercially available
Bio-Rad kit.
[35S]TBPS binding to membranes was measured by
incubating 100-µl samples of the membrane (25 µg) at room
temperature for 2 hr in the presence of 50 µl of
[35S]TBPS (5 nM final concentration; 98.5 Ci/mmol; NEN Products, Stevenage, Herts, U.K.) and 100 µl of assay
buffer with or without competing ligand (
-HCH,
-HCH,
-HCH and
-HCH) at concentrations ranging from 1 nM to 100 µM. Nonspecific
binding was determined with use of 100 µM cold TBPS. Bound
[35S]TBPS was separated from free
[35S]TBPS by vacuum filtration through Whatman
GF/B filters. All experiments were performed in triplicate.
Displacement data were fit to the equation described above.
Drugs.
Drugs used were: GABA (Sigma-Aldrich), picrotoxin
(Sigma-Aldrich),
- and
-HCH (Sigma-Aldrich), loreclezole (a gift
of Jannsens), 5
-pregnan-3
-ol-20-one (5
,3
-DHP)
(Sigma-Aldrich), lanthanum (Sigma-Aldrich), pentobarbital
(Sigma-Aldrich) and propofol (Aldrich Chemical Co., Gillingham, Dorset,
U.K.). The
- and
-HCH isomers were a gift from Dr Stuart Dunbar,
Zeneca Agrochemicals, U.K. Solutions of GABA were made in saline, while
loreclezole, 5
,3
-DHP, lanthanum, picrotoxin, propofol and HCH
isomers were prepared as 10
1 M or
10
2 M stocks in DMSO, while pentobarbital
was supplied as a 60 mg/ml solution in ethanol. The highest
concentration of DMSO or ethanol vehicle perfusing the oocyte was 1%,
which had no effects on GABA-induced currents.
 |
Results |
Effects of
-HCH and its
,
and
isomers on
GABA responses.
-HCH and its
,
and
isomers (fig.
1) were studied on recombinant human
GABAA
1
3
2S receptors to investigate
their effect on GABA-mediated responses. The isomers (100 µM) were
applied 30 sec before the coapplication of an
EC20 GABA concentration (or
EC50 for
-HCH). As shown in figure
2, the
- and
-HCH isomers potentiated the GABA-mediated response by about 150% and 185%, respectively, as well as the
isomer producing a small amount of
receptor activation in the absence of GABA. In contrast,
-HCH inhibited the GABA EC50 response by approximately
30%, and the
isomer had no significant effect. To elucidate the
mechanism underlying the two opposite effects of the HCH isomers, we
characterized the actions of
-HCH and its
isomer in more detail.

View larger version (14K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2.
Effects of HCH isomers on GABA responses in
oocytes expressing human 1 3 2S GABAA
receptors. Oocytes were clamped at 70 mV, and
EC20 or EC50 GABA responses
were elicited in the presence or absence of 100 µM HCH isomer. To
study potentiation of the GABAA receptor, a
submaximal EC20 concentration was chosen in (a),
(b) and (d). To measure inhibition with -HCH (c), an
EC50 concentration was used (see "Methods").
-HCH inhibited EC50 GABA responses, whereas
the and isomers clearly potentiated EC20 GABA responses, with -HCH having an additional direct action on
GABAA receptors. -HCH had no effect on
EC20 GABA-mediated currents.
|
|
- and
-HCH concentration-response curves.
To determine
the potency and efficacy of the two isomers on GABA responses in
oocytes expressing human
1
3
2S GABAA
receptors, concentration-response curves were constructed with an
EC20 concentration of GABA for the potentiation
by the
isomer and EC50 for the inhibition by
the
isomer determined on individual oocytes. Figure 3A shows that the effect of
-HCH was
concentration-dependent, giving a maximum inhibition of 33.8 ± 3.6% (n = 7), and gave no further inhibition at
concentrations greater than 10 µM. The EC50 for
-HCH was 1.0 ± 0.3 µM (n = 7). Similar
results have also been reported for Xenopus oocytes
expressing RNA from rat cerebral cortex (Woodward et al.,
1992
). Concentration-response curves for
-HCH potentiation of GABA
responses demonstrated a potentiation of the GABA
EC20 with a maximum of 216 ± 31%
(n = 7) (fig. 3B). The EC50 value
for
-HCH potentiation was 15.3 ± 3.7 µM (n = 7).

View larger version (21K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 3.
Concentration-response curves for the effects of
- and -HCH on GABA responses on oocytes expressing human
1 3 2S (filled circles) or 6 3 2S (open circles)
GABAA receptors. (a) The inhibitory action of
increasing concentrations of -HCH on EC50 GABA
responses was studied. (b) The effect of the isomer was analyzed on
EC20 GABA responses (see "Methods").
|
|
The alpha subunit of the GABAA
receptor influences the pharmacology of the GABA (Ebert et
al., 1994
), benzodiazepine (Pritchett et al., 1989
;
Wafford et al., 1993
) and barbiturate (Thompson et
al., 1996
) sites. To determine whether alpha subunit
composition could also influence the effects of
-HCH and its
isomer on GABA responses, we tested the effect of these compounds on
oocytes expressing the human
6
3
2S GABAA
receptor subtype. As shown in figure 3A, the effects of
-HCH on the
GABA responses mediated by
6
3
2S GABAA
receptors were not significantly different from the effects observed
with the
1
3
2S GABAA receptors, showing the same degree of maximal inhibition (30.8 ± 3.8%;
n = 6) and EC50 (1.3 ± 0.4 µM; n = 6). The maximum potentiation (342 ± 52%; n = 6) of the
6
3
2S receptor by the
isomer was not significantly higher than the value determined for the
1
3
2S subunit combination (fig. 3B). The
EC50 was also similar to that on
1
3
2S
(13.8 ± 3.4 µM; n = 6).
In addition to its positive allosteric effect,
-HCH directly
activated the GABAA receptor, which resembled the
effects of pentobarbital (Thompson et al., 1996
), propofol
(Orser et al., 1994
) and neuroactive steroids (Puia et
al., 1990
). The direct effect was observed at concentrations
higher than 1 µM, which is similar to the concentration range at
which barbiturate, propofol and neuroactive steroids activate
GABAA receptors. The maximum efficacy and
EC50 were similar for both
1
3
2
(22.7 ± 2.6% of a maximum GABA response; 53.6 ± 10.5 µM;
n = 5) and
6
3
2 (18 ± 3.3% of a maximum
GABA response; 39.2 ± 5.2 µM; n = 7) subunit combinations (fig. 4).

View larger version (19K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 4.
Concentration-response curve for the direct effect
of -HCH on oocytes expressing 1 3 2S (filled circles) or
6 3 2S (open circles) GABAA receptors.
Each point represents the arithmetic mean ± S.E.M. calculated as
a percentage of the response obtained with a maximum concentration of
GABA (3 mM).
|
|
Effects of
- and
-HCH on picrotoxin inhibition of
GABA responses of
1
3
2S GABAA
receptors.
Because
-HCH gave only partial inhibition of
the GABA EC50 response, we determined whether
either of the isomers could interact with the picrotoxin binding site.
We studied the effect of these compounds on picrotoxin inhibition of
GABA responses on the
1
3
2S subunit combination. As shown in
figure 5A, both
-HCH and the
isomer when coapplied with picrotoxin could reverse the inhibitory effect of picrotoxin on GABA responses. Figure 5B shows that the concentration-response curve for picrotoxin inhibition of GABA responses was shifted to the right by coapplication of
-HCH in a
dose-dependent manner, with EC50 values of
1.3 ± 0.3 µM (n = 4), 7.0 ± 2.1 µM
(n = 4) in 10 µM
-HCH, and 116.2 ± 30.9 µM
(n = 5) in 100 µM
-HCH, which suggested that
-HCH is a competitive inhibitor at the picrotoxin site. The
isomer also produced a similar rightward shift of the picrotoxin
dose-response curve (fig. 5B), which suggested that this isomer too
displaces picrotoxin from its binding site.

View larger version (21K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 5.
The effect of - and -HCH on
picrotoxin-mediated inhibition of GABA responses on oocytes expressing
human 1 3 2S GABAA receptors. (a) Both
- and -HCH reversed the inhibitory action of picrotoxin on
EC50 GABA responses. Cells were voltage-clamped
at 70 mV and exposed to GABA, picrotoxin and HCH isomers as indicated
by the bars above each trace. (b) The effect of 10 µM (open
triangles) and 100 µM (open squares) -HCH, and 100 µM -HCH
(filled triangles) on concentration-response curves for
picrotoxin-mediated inhibition of EC50 GABA
responses (filled circles). Each point represents the arithmetic
mean ± S.E.M. of four or five experiments.
|
|
To confirm that
- and
-HCH interact competitively with the
picrotoxin site, we carried out [35S]TBPS
displacement studies in membrane homogenates of a mouse cell line
expressing
1
3
2S GABAA receptors. Figure
6 shows the effect of
-HCH and its
,
and
isomers on the binding of 5 nM
[35S]TBPS. Both
-HCH and
-HCH inhibited
the specific binding of 5 nM [35S]TBPS in a
concentration-dependent manner with IC50 values
of 60 ± 10 nM (n = 4) and 1.2 ± 0.02 µM
(n = 4), respectively.
-HCH also inhibited
[35S]TBPS binding (IC50 = .5 ± 0.08 µM). As expected, the
isomer had no significant
effect on [35S]TBPS binding.

View larger version (27K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 6.
Concentration-effect curves for the inhibition of
[35S]TBPS-specific binding by HCH isomers in a
mouse fibroblast cell line expressing human 1 3 2S
GABAA receptors. HCH isomers plotted are -HCH
(open hexagon); -HCH (open triangle); -HCH (filled square); and
-HCH (filled circle). The data for each HCH isomer represent four
independent experiments. HCH isomers (1 nM to 100 µM) were incubated
with membrane homogenates and 5 nM [35S]TBPS.
|
|
The effect of
-HCH on
-HCH-dependent potentiation
of GABA responses of
1
3
2S GABAA
receptors.
To test whether
-HCH had any effect on the positive
potentiating action of
-HCH, we examined the effect of 10 µM and
100 µM
-HCH on the concentration-response curve of
-HCH
potentiation in oocytes expressing
1
3
2S
GABAA receptors. As shown in figure 7, 10 µM
-HCH reduced the maximum
potentiation of the GABA EC20 induced by the
isomer from 216 ± 31% to 139 ± 13% without causing a
shift in the EC50 value of the
-HCH-dependent
potentiation. When the experiment was repeated with 100 µM
-HCH,
the potentiation was completely blocked (fig. 7). These studies suggest
that
-HCH can allosterically affect the potentiation of GABA
responses by the
isomer.

View larger version (20K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 7.
The effect of -HCH on -HCH-mediated
potentiation of GABA responses on oocytes expressing the human
1 3 2S GABAA receptors. The
concentration-response curve for -HCH-induced potentiation of
EC20 GABA responses was obtained in the absence
(open circles) and presence of 10 µM (open square) or 100 µM
(filled circle) -HCH. Each point represents the arithmetic mean ± S.E.M. of four or seven experiments.
|
|
Effects of
-HCH on other positive modulators of the
GABAA receptor.
To characterize in
more detail the effect of the
isomer, we tested the effect of 100 µM
-HCH on the positive allosteric action of several modulators of
the GABAA receptor. As shown in figure
8 saturating concentrations of
loreclezole (10 µM), 5
-pregnan-3
-ol-20-one (300 nM), lanthanum
(1 mM), pentobarbital (100 µM) and propofol (10 µM) caused a
potentiation of the GABA response. Coapplication of 100 µM
-HCH
had an additive effect with the potentiation mediated by loreclezole,
5
-pregnan-3
-ol-20-one and lanthanum, which indicated that
-HCH
potentiation is not mediated through any of these binding sites. In
contrast,
-HCH either gave no further potentiation, or reduced the
potentiation mediated by either pentobarbital or propofol (fig. 8, D
and E, respectively), which suggested that that
-HCH may act through
a site common to both propofol and pentobarbital. To determine whether
pentobarbital and propofol interacted with the same site, we carried
out additive experiments with these two compounds. As shown in figure
8F, the effects of propofol and pentobarbital show some additivity when
combined. In addition,
-HCH inhibited the direct activation of the
receptor by pentobarbital (data not shown).

View larger version (12K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 8.
Effects of -HCH on the potentiation of GABA
responses induced by positive allosteric modulators of the
GABAA receptor. Oocytes expressing human
1 3 2S GABAA receptors were
voltage-clamped at 70 mV and exposed to an EC20
concentration of GABA (G), followed by the allosteric modulator alone,
followed by this in combination with 100 µM -HCH ( -HCH), as
indicated by the bars above each trace. Traces show (a) 10 µM
loreclezole (Lor), (b) 300 nM 5 -pregnan-3 -ol-20-one (5 ), (c) 1 mM lanthanum (Lan), (d) 100 µM pentobarbital (Pen) and (e) 10 µM
propofol (Pro). Trace (f) shows the combination of pentobarbital (100 µM) and propofol (10 µM). Traces are typical of at least four
experiments in each case.
|
|
Effects of
-HCH on pentobarbital potentiation of the
GABA response.
In light of the previous finding that
-HCH could
allosterically inhibit
-HCH potentiation, we investigated whether
-HCH had any effect on the potentiation by the barbiturate
pentobarbital. As shown in figure 9, 100 µM
-HCH inhibited the dose-dependent potentiation of the
EC20 GABA responses of
1
3
2S
GABAA receptors by pentobarbital, which suggested
that, in addition to its effect on the picrotoxin binding site,
-HCH
has an allosteric effect inhibiting barbiturate potentiation.

View larger version (19K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 9.
Concentration-response curves for pentobarbital,
with (filled circle) and without (open circle) 100 µM -HCH, on
oocytes expressing human 1 3 2S GABAA
receptors. Each point represents the arithmetic mean ± S.E.M. of
four experiments and calculated as percentage of
EC20 potentiation.
|
|
 |
Discussion |
In the present study, we have shown that
-HCH and its
and
isomers interact with human
1
3
2S or
6
3
2S
GABAA receptors expressed in oocytes, which
supports the view that these substances act primarily at
GABAA receptors. In contrast, we found that the
isomer is essentially inactive on either GABA responses or
[35S]TBPS binding, confirming previous
suggestions that this isomer is essentially a non-GABAergic HCH isomer
(Woodward et al., 1992
; Nagata and Narahashi, 1995
).
However, a depressant action for the
isomer has been well
substantiated (Vohland et al., 1981
; Stark et
al., 1986
), and Pomés et al. (1994)
has
demonstrated a biphasic action (positive modulation at concentrations
lower than 1 µM and inhibition at higher concentrations) of
-HCH
on GABA-dependent 36Cl
uptake into primary cultures of rat neocortical neurons. It is not easy
to solve these discrepancies, but it is possible that differences in
intracellular signaling mechanisms in different preparations and the
ability of HCH isomers to interact with intracellular targets such as
ryanodine-sensitive calcium channels (Pessah et al., 1992
)
may account for them. Thus, the presence of HCH-sensitive intracellular
receptors in a preparation may result in the activation of kinase
enzymes, which are known to modulate the activity of GABAA receptors (Leidenheimer et al.,
1992
).
-HCH suppresses GABA-induced currents in dorsal root ganglion
neurons (Nagata and Narahashi, 1995
), insect neurons (Wafford et
al., 1988
; Bermudez et al., 1991
) and oocytes
expressing mammalian GABAA (Woodward et
al., 1992
) or Drosophila GABA (Zhang et al., 1994
; Belelli et al., 1995
) receptors.
-HCH also
inhibited GABA currents on oocytes expressing human
1
3
2S or
6
3
2S GABAA receptors with an
EC50 value of about 1 µM, which is in agreement with values reported for other mammalian preparations (Woodward et al., 1992
; Nagata and Narahashi, 1995
). Our studies
showed
-HCH to be a partial inhibitor of GABAA
receptors, suppressing EC50 GABA responses by a
maximum of 34%. Partial inhibition of GABA-induced currents by
-HCH
has also been demonstrated by Woodward et al. (1992)
in
Xenopus oocytes expressing rat or bovine
GABAA receptors. However, full
-HCH-induced
inhibition has been reported for dorsal root ganglion neurons (Nagata
and Narahashi, 1995
) and Xenopus oocytes expressing a
Drosophila GABA receptor subunit (Zhang et al.,
1994
). This suggests that the degree of efficacy may depend on the type
of GABA receptor subunits present; we have shown here that it is
unlikely to be caused by different alpha subunits.
-HCH acts in a similar fashion to picrotoxin. For example, there are
several reports showing
-HCH-induced inhibition of [35S]TBPS binding to neuronal membranes
(Lawrence and Casida, 1984
; Llorens et al., 1990
) and
GABA-mediated 36Cl
fluxes
(Abalis et al., 1986
; Pomés et al., 1994
).
The binding site of picrotoxin is likely to be in the M2 region of the
Cl channel as suggested by site-directed mutagenesis studies of the putative M2 domain of rho receptors (Wang et al.,
1995
),
-glycine receptor subunits (Pribilla et al., 1992
)
and a Drosophila GABA subunit (ffrench-Constant et
al., 1993
; Belelli et al., 1995
). Interestingly,
mutations of the picrotoxin site (alanine 302) in a
Drosophila GABA subunit decreases the potency of both
picrotoxin and
-HCH inhibition (Zhang et al., 1994;
Belelli et al., 1995
), which suggests that these two
compounds interact with identical residues in the M2 region of
GABAA receptors.
It is not clear as yet whether picrotoxin, and hence
-HCH, inhibits
GABA responses by merely obstructing the Cl channel or by allosteric
blockade. Studies showing that picrotoxin binds preferentially to the
desensitized conformation of GABAA receptors in
sympathetic rat neurons (Newland and Cull-Candy, 1992
), and that
-HCH accelerates the desensitization of GABAA
receptors in dorsal root ganglion neurons (Nagata and Narahashi, 1995
), suggest that picrotoxin and
-HCH are allosteric inhibitors of the
GABAA receptor. Thus, by analogy to the
benzodiazepine site, we propose that picrotoxin is a full inverse
agonist of the picrotoxin modulatory site. In contrast,
-HCH, which
both partially blocks GABA responses mediated by
GABAA receptors expressed in Xenopus oocytes (this study; Woodward et al., 1992
) and relieves
picrotoxin-induced inhibition of human GABAA
receptors (this study), behaves as a partial inverse agonist of the
picrotoxin site. This action is similar to that of fluorinated
methylbutyrolactone, which has also been proposed to be a partial
inverse agonist of the picrotoxin site (Yoon et al., 1990
).
In other preparations such as dorsal root ganglion neurons,
-HCH may
act as a full inverse agonist, presumably reflecting species or GABA
receptor subtype differences.
-HCH potentiates GABA responses in Xenopus oocytes
expressing rat and bovine GABAA (Woodward
et al., 1992
), Drosophila GABA (Belelli et
al., 1996
) receptors, dorsal root ganglion (Nagata and Narahashi,
1995
) and cortical (Pomés et al., 1994
) neurons. We
also observed
-HCH-dependent potentiation of human
1
3
2S and
6
3
2S GABAA receptors.
-HCH
potentiation was not influenced by alpha subunit
composition, which is in contrast to other positive allosteric
modulators of the GABAA receptor such as
barbiturates (Thompson et al., 1996
) and benzodiazepines
(Wafford et al., 1993
)
Several lines of evidence argue against the idea of an identical
binding locus for the
and
isomers. First, a A302S mutant of a
Drosophila GABA subunit receptor shows reduced
susceptibility to inhibition by picrotoxin and
-HCH without changes
in its affinity toward the positive allosteric modulator
-HCH
(Belelli et al., 1995
). Second, rho receptors are
endowed with a picrotoxin binding locus but lack a site for positive
allosteric modulation by the
isomer (Woodward et al.,
1992
; Wang et al., 1995
). However, the two sites may be
close, adjacent or even overlapping, which could explain the inhibition
of
-HCH-dependent effects by the
isomer, as well as the
inhibition of picrotoxin antagonism by the
isomer. Alternatively
the
-HCH activity at the picrotoxin site may be masked by its
potentiating effect, and only when pentobarbital is used as an agonist
is the inhibition observed. The inhibition of
-HCH potentiation by
-HCH is clearly not a competitive interaction because the inhibition
cannot be overcome at high concentrations, and the
-HCH
EC50 is not affected. This would suggest an
allosteric interaction between the two sites.
Clues as to where the
-HCH site might be located come from our
observation that the
isomer reduces the positive allosteric action
of both pentobarbital and propofol. Although neither the barbiturate or
propofol sites have been defined as yet, there is neurochemical
evidence to suggest that they are separate entities (Concas et
al., 1991
), with the alpha and beta subunits
probably contributing to the barbiturate site (Amin and Weiss, 1993
;
Thompson et al., 1996
). The effect of
-HCH on the
enhancement action of pentobarbital and propofol may be explained then
by postulating that the
-HCH locus overlaps with the barbiturate and
propofol sites, which are close or adjacent to each other. The
observation that rho receptors, which are insensitive to
positive allosteric modulation by
-HCH are insensitive to
barbiturates and propofol (Bormann and Feigenspan, 1995
) further
support the idea of three separate though overlapping loci. It is
unlikely that the
-HCH site is linked to other sites such as the
benzodiazepine site, because flumazenil, an antagonist of the
benzodiazepine site, has no effect on
-HCH-mediated potentiation of
GABA responses (Woodward et al., 1992
).
We demonstrated a direct action of
-HCH on
GABAA receptors, which has not been reported
previously. This action resembled the direct activation of
GABAA receptors by barbiturates (Belelli et
al., 1996
; Thompson et al., 1996
) and propofol (Orser
et al., 1994
; Belelli et al., 1996
). Direct
activation of GABAA receptors by barbiturates
(Mathers and Barker, 1980
; Thompson et al., 1996
) and
propofol (Orser et al., 1994
) is not mediated through the GABA binding site (Thompson et al., 1996
; Ueno et
al., 1997
), which suggests that the site for direct activation by
the
isomer is a separate locus from the agonist site. Recent
evidence suggests that homomeric beta subunits form
receptors that can be gated by barbiturates and propofol (Sanna
et al., 1995
; Krishek et al., 1996
), but only
weakly by GABA, which suggests a role for the beta subunit
in this activation. Because the
-HCH isomer seems to be acting
via a site common to these compounds, it may also be
activating the receptor in a similar manner, although to a lesser
extent than pentobarbital or propofol. A single channel approach as
well as the use of pharmacological tools such as competitive inhibitors
of the GABA binding site might help to define more precisely this site.
Accepted for publication May 5, 1997.
Received for publication February 25, 1997.