![]() |
|
|
Vol. 282, Issue 2, 1055-1063, 1997
Department of Pharmacology, Temple University School of Medicine, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
| |
Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Intracerebral microdialysis was used to measure changes in the extracellular level of substance P (SP) released from the periaqueductal gray (PAG) and the preoptic anterior hypothalamus (POAH) of freely moving Sprague-Dawley rats after noxious cold stimulation. Artificial cerebrospinal fluid was perfused into the dialysis probe in the PAG or POAH and samples were collected every 30 min for 4 hr. SP-like immunoreactivity in the samples was measured by radioimmunoassay. In the PAG, SP base-line release was 0.43 ± 0.08 fmol/fraction. SP release was increased to 1.3 ± 0.4 fmol/fraction during the first collection period after noxious cold. Pretreatment with the selective mu opioid receptor agonist PL017 (0.8-3.4 nmol) or the kappa opioid receptor agonist dynorphin A1-17 (4.6-9.2 nmol), administered into the PAG by microinjection, produced dose-related inhibition of the cold-evoked SP release. Naloxone (10 mg/kg s.c.) administration 10 min before these opioid agonists reduced the inhibition of SP release. In the POAH, SP base-line release was 0.45 ± 0.06 fmol/fraction and noxious cold did not cause any significant change in SP release. Microdialysis of SP (271 fmol-271 pmol/µl/min, for 30 min) into the PAG, but not the POAH, induced dose-related analgesia (35-68% MPA) in the cold-water tail-flick test. However, microdialysis of SP into the POAH or PAG failed to induce any significant change in body temperature. These data suggest that 1) SP released from the PAG acts as a neuromodulator to transmit nociceptive information; 2) opioid receptor agonists can suppress this information by inhibiting SP release; 3) SP evoked by noxious cold may have a role in triggering the antinociceptive function of the PAG; and 4) SP does not appear to act as a neuromodulator for thermoregulatory responses in the POAH.
| |
Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
SP
is either a neurotransmitter or a neuromodulator in conduction of
nociceptive information in the CNS (Marx, 1979
). During noxious cold or
mechanical stimuli, the SP release level is increased in the spinal
cord (Kuraishi et al., 1985
; Tiseo et al., 1990
) and this increased SP release can be inhibited by pretreatment with
opioids (Kuraishi et al., 1983
; Tiseo et al.,
1990
; Yaksh et al., 1980
). These findings suggest that SP
may carry or modulate noxious signals to the CNS and that opioids
produce their analgesic effects by suppressing SP release. It has been
proposed that SP can be released not only from the spinal cord but also
from the brain regions that are involved in endogenous pain
suppression, such as the PAG, to transmit afferent noxious signals and
activate the pain-modulating pathway descending from the PAG (Basbaum
and Fields, 1984
). Indeed, SP-immunoreactive neurons, nerve terminals (Hökfelt et al., 1977
; Moss and Basbaum, 1983
) and
receptors (Quirion et al., 1983
) can be observed in the PAG.
Some of the ascending inputs to the PAG from the spinal cord contain SP
(Noguchi and Ruda, 1992
). SP can be released from brain tissue slices
(Iversen et al., 1976
; Calvo et al., 1990
) or
certain brain regions in vivo (Brodin et al.,
1983
; Lindefors et al., 1986
, 1987
; Morilak et
al., 1988
) by stimulation with potassium. The findings that SP
microinjection into the PAG produces naloxone-reversible analgesia (Malick and Goldstein, 1978
; Mohrland and Gebhart, 1979
) and that opioids inhibit SP release from the brain (Micevych et al.,
1982
; Rosen and Brodin, 1989) suggest that SP within the brain may play a neuromodulatory role in transmitting nociceptive information and
interact with either endogenous opioid peptides or exogenous opioid
drugs. A previous report from our laboratory has shown that noxious
cold stimulation to the rat's tail induced elevation of SP release
from the spinal cord, whereas noxious heat induced elevation of
somatostatin release (Tiseo et al., 1990
). The SP increase
could be inhibited by i.c.v. pretreatment with Dyn. It is not known,
however, if noxious cold can also induce an increase of SP in the
brain. SP release from brain regions in vivo is detectable by a combination of intracerebral microdialysis and RIA methods (Brodin
et al., 1983
; Lindefors et al., 1986
, 1987
).
In the present study, with use of intracerebral microdialysis and RIA,
we investigated SP release from the PAG after noxious cold-water
stimulation with or without pretreatment with the mu opioid
receptor agonist PL017 or the kappa opioid receptor agonist Dyn. We reported previously that both drugs produce analgesic effects
when dialyzed into the PAG in the CWT (Xin et al., 1993
). For comparison, we also investigated whether noxious cold could induce
any change in SP release level from another brain region, i.e., the POAH, which is a primary site for Tb regulation
and contains SP nerve terminals and receptors (Panula et
al., 1984
). Finally, SP was perfused into the PAG and POAH to
examine its effects on analgesia and Tb.
| |
Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Animals. Male Sprague-Dawley rats (Zivic-Miller, Pittsburgh, PA) weighing 250-300 g were used in this study. They were housed three per cage for at least 1 week before surgery and were fed laboratory chow and tap water ad libitum. The temperature of the room was 22 ± 2°C and a 12-hr light/12-hr dark cycle was used.
Microdialysis probe preparation.
The microdialysis probes
used in this study were constructed in a concentric shape consisting of
a 1.5-mm length of hollow tubular dialysis membrane
(acrylonitrile-sodium methallyl sulfonate, 40-kdalton molecular weight
cutoff, 230 µm internal diameter, 300 µm outside diameter, Hospal,
Uden, The Netherlands) with the tip sealed by epoxy resin and the other
end mounted to a 26-gauge thin-wall stainless steel cannula (15-mm
length, Small Parts, Inc., Miami Lakes, FL). A 22-mm length of thin
polyimide-coated fused silica tubing (75 µm internal diameter, 140 µm outside diameter, Polymicro Technologies, Phoenix, AZ) as an inlet
was threaded through the stainless steel cannula into the dialysis
membrane, leaving approximately 0.4 mm free between the end of the
silica tubing and the epoxy at the tip of the dialysis membrane.
Another 22-mm length of fused silica tubing as an outlet was also
threaded through the stainless steel cannula into the upper end of the dialysis membrane. The upper end of the stainless steel cannula was
sealed by epoxy after both inlet and outlet silica tubing were
inserted. For administration of opioid agonists, a 30-mm length of
fused silica tubing was attached to the outside of the stainless steel
cannula to form a side catheter, with its tip near the tip of the
dialysis membrane. The upper ends of inlet, outlet and side catheter
were each connected with a length of PE-10 tubing. A schematic drawing
of the probe with attached cathether is shown in figure
1.
|
Surgery and probe implantation.
Rats were anesthetized with
an i.m. injection of a mixture of ketamine hydrochloride (100-150
mg/kg) and acepromazine maleate (0.2 mg/kg) and stereotaxically
(Pellegrino and Cushman, 1967
) implanted unilaterally with a guide
cannula (21-gauge stainless steel tubing, 14 mm long, Small Parts,
Inc., Miami Lakes, FL) into the location above the PAG (AP, 0.6; R,
0.8; V, 1.0) or POAH (AP, 7.8; R, 1.0; V,
1.0). A stylet was inserted
into the guide cannula, which was fixed with dental cement and
self-tapping bone screws. A slotted hex head screw (Instech
Laboratories, Inc., Plymouth Meeting, PA) was inversely fixed on the
skull behind the cannula with dental cement for attachment of a tether.
After surgery, animals were housed individually to prevent them from destroying the cannula and were allowed to recover from the surgery at
least 7 days. One day before the experiment, the rat was anesthetized again with ketamine and the stylet was replaced by a microdialysis probe, so that its dialysis membrane tip protruded exactly 1.5 mm
beyond the guide and was located within the PAG or POAH. aCSF (see
"Materials") was injected into the side catheter (0.2 µl) from
its inlet to avoid the injection of air into the brain during the
experiment, after which the inlet was sealed.
Materials.
The following drugs were tested: mu
opioid receptor agonist PL017
(Tyr-Pro-N-MePhe-D-Pro-NH2);
kappa opioid receptor agonist Dyn (both from Multiple
Peptide Systems, San Diego, CA); naloxone (Nal, DuPont Merck
Pharmaceutical Co., Wilmington, DE), and SP (Peninsula Laboratories,
Inc., Belmont, CA). aCSF (composition in mM: NaCl, 125; KCl, 2.5;
NaH2PO4, 0.5;
Na2HPO4, 5;
CaCl2, 1.2; MgCl2, 1;
ascorbic acid, 0.1; and bovine serum albumen, 0.025%, pH 7.4) was the
vehicle and control solution. SP antiserum was prepared in rabbits and
was generously provided by Dr. Susan E. Leeman of Boston University.
The final dilution of the antiserum used was 1:180,000. Half-maximal
displacement was 2 fmol/250 µl. Cross-reactivities of this antiserum
were such that no measurable displacement was observed at 100 pM with
substance K, met-enkephalin, somatostatin or physalaemin. Isotope
[125I]Tyr8-SP was
purchased from Dupont New England Nuclear Research Products (Boston,
MA). The second antiserum (goat anti-rabbit
-globulin), used for
separation of anti-SP-bound tracer from free tracer, was purchased from
Calbiochem Corporation (La Jolla, CA).
Microdialysis in vivo experiments.
On the test
day, the rat was placed into an individual plastic cage where it could
move freely in an environmental room kept at 21 ± 0.3°C and
52 ± 2% relative humidity. A light-weight stainless steel spring
tether (30.5 cm, M105, Instech Laboratories, Inc., Plymouth Meeting,
PA) was connected to the screw captured in the head block by inserting
the tether blade into the slot of the screw. A small tubular nut locked
the tether in place. The upper end of the tether was attached to the
clamp of a single-channel swivel (series 375, Instech Laboratories,
Inc., Plymouth Meeting, PA) which was held on a lever arm. A length of
PE-10 tubing was threaded through the tether and connected with the
output of the swivel and the input cannula of the dialysis probe. The
input of the swivel was then connected to a 1-ml tuberculin syringe (Becton Dickinson & Co., Rutherford, NJ) clamped to a perfusion pump
(Harvard Apparatus, Inc., South Natick, MA). The output of the probe
was connected with a length of PE-10 tubing fed into a 1.5-ml
polyethylene collection tube which was mounted in a tube holder clipped
on the tether just over the rat's head. aCSF was continually perfused
into the dialysis probe at a rate of 4 µl/min. After at least a 1-hr
perfusion for equilibrium, dialysate samples were collected every 30 min for 240 min. Samples were frozen immediately after collection and
stored at
70°C until assayed. The first three samples were
collected as base-line release for SP. The noxious cold stimulus was
performed by placing the rat's tail into a circulating cold water bath
(model 9500, Fisher Scientific, Pittsburgh, PA) until the animal
flicked its tail or reached cutoff time (20 sec/min), in a 1:1 mix of
ethylene glycol/water maintained at
10°C. The cold stimulus was
given five times during a 5-min test period. In some cases, a water
bath of 25°C was also used as a control. The mu opioid
receptor agonist PL017 (0.8-3.4 nmol), the kappa opioid
receptor agonist Dyn (2.3-9.2 nmol) or aCSF was microinjected in a
volume of 0.5 µl into the brain region through the side catheter
attached to the dialysis probe 5 min before the noxious cold stimulus.
In two groups, Nal (10 mg/kg) was administered s.c. 10 min before
microinjection of PL017 or Dyn into the PAG.
RIA. In each RIA, standard curves were constructed for SP by use of known amounts of synthetic standards ranging from 0.1 to 24 fmol. The assay was carried out directly in the tubes used for collection of the dialysate fractions during microdialysis. The dialysate fractions (120 µl) and the SP standards in aCSF (120 µl) were preincubated with rabbit antiserum against SP (80 µl) for 24 hr at 4°C. After addition of [125I]Tyr8-SP (2500-3500 cpm in 80 µl; approximate specific activity 81 TBq/mmol = 1480 µCi/µg), all samples were further incubated for 24 hr at 4°C. To separate bound from free tracer, the second antiserum was added to each assay tube at the end of incubation as recommended by the manufacturer. All assay tubes were vortexed briefly and centrifuged for 20 min at 760 × g by a refrigerated SUREspin centrifuge at 4°C. The supernatant was carefully decanted and the precipitate containing antibody-bound [125I]Tyr8-SP was counted in a gamma counter (NE-1600, Nuclear Enterprises, Scotland, UK). Levels of SP were then calculated by linear regression analysis derived from logarithmic transformation of data determined for known amounts of synthetic SP. Separate samples without standards and additional samples also without antibodies were incubated simultaneously to measure maximal tracer binding and unspecific binding, respectively. The detection limit of this assay was 0.2 fmol/250 µl.
Microdialysis in vitro. In vitro recovery of SP through the acrylonitrile membrane was determined by placing microdialysis probes in aCSF solution (200 µl, at 37°C bath) containing 1 nM synthetic SP. The probes were continuously perfused at a flow rate of 4 µl/min. After equilibrium, three 120-µl samples of perfusate were collected and assayed for SP by RIA as described above. The SP-containing aCSF solution was also assayed. The recovery of the probe membrane was determined by calculating the percentage of the SP concentration in the perfusate versus that in the medium solution. The in vitro recovery of this dialysis membrane for SP was 1.9 ± 0.6% (mean ± S.E.M., n = 6). The percentage of the amount of SP that may bind to the probe material or tubing was 0.2 ± 0.12% (mean ± S.E.M., n = 5). This was estimated by the difference between the SP amount in the input solution and the sum of SP amount in the both perfusate and medium solutions.
Analgesia testing.
Separate experiments were conducted to
investigate the analgesic effect of SP microdialyzed into the PAG or
POAH of the rat. The microdialysis system used to deliver SP into the
PAG or POAH was similar to that described above (see "Microdialysis
in Vivo Experiments") without the sample collecting and
microinjecting procedures. At the beginning, aCSF was continuously
perfused into the brain regions at 4 µl/min. The CWT was used to
assess the analgesic effects of SP according to standard procedures in
our laboratory (Tiseo et al., 1988
). Animals were held
firmly over the water bath (
10°C) and their tails submerged
approximately half-way into the solution. The nociceptive threshold was
taken as the latency until the rat removed or flicked its tail. Three latencies were measured: 60, 30 and 0 min before drug perfusion. For
each animal, the first reading was discarded to minimize variability, and the remaining two were averaged to determine the base-line latency.
After the predrug latency measurements, the input solution was switched
to the SP-containing aCSF (27.1 fmol-271 pmol/µl) and was
continuously perfused at 4 µl/min for 30 min. The latency to
tail-flick was tested at the end of SP perfusion and 15, 30, 60 and 120 min after that. If an animal did not respond within 60 sec, the trial
was terminated and a maximum latency of 60 sec was recorded. The
analgesic effect of SP treatment was calculated for each rat as
follows: percent maximum possible analgesia (% MPA) = [(postdrug
latency
base-line latency)/(60-base-line latency)] × 100. In
some cases, Nal in a dose of 10 mg/kg was injected s.c. 10 min before
the CWT to investigate the effect of Nal injection alone on the
tail-flick response. Testing was also carried out after pretreatment
with Nal (10 mg/kg s.c.) 10 min before the low dose (27.1 fmol/µl) or
high dose (271 pmol/µl) of SP perfusion.
Tb response testing.
Effects on Tb of SP microdialyzed into
the PAG or POAH were also investigated in separate experiments. The
microdialysis procedure was the same as that used in the analgesia
testing. Tb measurements were made according to standard procedures in
our laboratory (Geller et al., 1986
). After a 1-hr
acclimation period, a thermistor probe (YSI series 400, Yellow Springs
Instrument Co., Inc., Yellow Springs, OH) was lubricated and inserted
approximately 7 cm into the rectum. The rat was lightly hand-held by
the tail, but was otherwise free to move. Tb measurements were read
from a digital thermometer (model 49 TA, YSI). The first three
measurements were taken at 30-min intervals. To allow for adaptation to
the procedure, the first reading was discarded and the subsequent two
averaged to establish a base line. After the third measurement, the
input solution was switched to SP-containing aCSF and perfused at 4 µl/min for 30 min. Tb was measured at the end of SP perfusion and 15, 30, 45, 60, 90 and 120 min later.
Verification of dialysis probe placement.
At the end of the
experiments, rats were placed for at least 10 min into a bucket
containing dry ice within a metal mesh basket. The animals were almost
instantaneously anesthetized by the carbon dioxide, rapidly asphyxiated
and cooled. Their brains were excised and coronally cut; the visible
track of the microdialysis probe was checked. In some cases,
bromophenol blue (0.2%) was microdialyzed into the PAG or POAH for 30 min after the experiment ended. The brains were removed, rapidly frozen
and stored at
70°C. A block of tissue containing the track of the
probe and the stain of the dialyzed dye was cut and checked (fig.
2). Data from rats in which the probes
were not located within the PAG or POAH were not included in the
results.
|
Data presentation and statistical analysis.
The results for
SP are reported as mean ± S.E.M. values of the measured dialysate
concentrations. The results for the analgesic effect of SP are reported
as % MPA (mean ± S.E.M.). The results for the Tb effect of SP
are expressed as Tb changes (
T, mean ± S.E.M.) from base line.
The changes of cold-evoked SP release in the groups pretreated with
opioid agonists and Nal are expressed as the percentage of cold-evoked
SP in the group without pretreatment. In the experiment that examined
the effects of pretreatment with opioid agonists and Nal on cold-evoked
SP release, data were evaluated by a one-way analysis of variance
followed by a post hoc Fisher's test. Other experimental
data were analyzed by a repeated-measures analysis of variance model,
in which factor 1 was treatment and factor 2 was time. The 5% level of
probability was accepted as statistically significant.
| |
Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
SP base-line release from the PAG and POAH. The average basal release of SP from the PAG was 0.43 ± 0.08 fmol/fraction during the 3-hr collection period (table 1). In the POAH, SP base-line release was 0.45 ± 0.06 fmol/fraction during the 3-hr collection period.
|
SP release from the PAG after noxious cold stimulation.
SP
release level was significantly increased to 1.3 ± 0.4 fmol/fraction during the collection period of 30 min after noxious cold
stimulation and then returned to base-line level during the next
collection period (fig. 3, top). In
contrast, 25°C water did not produce any significant change in SP
released from the PAG.
|
SP release from the POAH after noxious cold stimulation. Neither noxious cold nor 25°C water stimuli evoked any significant change in the level of SP released from the POAH (fig. 3, bottom).
Effects of pretreatment with PL017 in the PAG on SP release evoked
by noxious cold.
Although aCSF microinjection into the PAG did not
affect the SP increase evoked by cold, PL017 microinjected into the PAG significantly reduced the SP release evoked by noxious cold in a
dose-dependent manner (fig. 4, top).
PL017, in a dose of 0.8 nmol, reduced the cold-evoked SP increase level
to an average 0.48 fmol/fraction increase over base-line, a 42%
reduction compared with that in the aCSF-pretreatment group (0.84 fmol/fraction equals 100%). PL017, in dose of 1.7 nmol, reduced that
SP increase 66% and 3.4 nmol, 89%, compared with that in the
aCSF-pretreatment group. These doses of PL017 were capable of producing
analgesia (40% MPA-85% MPA) in the CWT in earlier studies (Adams
et al., 1993
; Xin et al., 1993
).
|
Effects of pretreatment with Dyn in the PAG on SP release evoked by
noxious cold.
Pretreatment with Dyn administered into the PAG also
produced an inhibition in SP release evoked by noxious cold (fig. 4, bottom). Dyn, in doses of 4.6 and 9.2 nmol, reduced the elevation in SP
release evoked by noxious cold to an average 0.54 and 0.11 fmol/fraction increase over base line, respectively, a 36 to 87% reduction compared with that in the aCSF-pretreatment group (0.84 fmol/fraction equals 100%). These doses of Dyn were capable of producing analgesia (28% MPA-70% MPA) in the CWT, as reported previously (Tiseo et al., 1988
; Xin et al.,
1993
). Dyn, in a dose of 2.3 nmol, did not induce significant changes
in cold-evoked SP increase.
Effect of Nal on the inhibition of cold-evoked SP release caused by PL017 and Dyn. Nal (10 mg/kg) administered s.c. 10 min before PL017 or Dyn microinjection reduced the inhibition of cold-evoked SP increase by these opioid agonists. The 89% reduction of SP increase caused by PL017 (3.4 nmol) was decreased to a 7% reduction when Nal was given before PL017 (fig. 4, top). The 87% reduction of SP increase caused by Dyn (9.2 nmol) was decreased to only 6% when Nal was given before Dyn (fig. 4, bottom).
Effects of SP microdialyzed into the PAG and POAH on the latency to
tail-flick.
The lowest dose (27.1 fmol/µl) of SP microdialyzed
into the PAG produced a slight but not significant increase in latency to tail-flick in the CWT (fig. 5). After
a 30-min perfusion at this dose, the amount of SP delivered into the
PAG can be estimated at as much as 65 fmol, which is the mean amount of
extracellular SP evoked by cold, according to the in vitro
recovery rate of the probe for SP. However, higher doses of SP
microdialyzed into the PAG produced a dose-related analgesia. SP in a
dose of 271 fmol/µl, which is 10 times higher than the lowest dose,
induced 30% MPA at 30 min after the end of SP perfusion; and SP, in a dose of 27.1 pmol/µl, induced 41% MPA at 15 min. SP, in doses of 271 pmol/µl, produced 35% MPA at the end of the perfusion and 65% MPA
15 min later. The analgesic effect lasted until 30 min after the end of
perfusion (38% MPA). However, SP, in doses which could produce
analgesia when given into the PAG, did not induce any significant
change in the tail-flick latency when it was microdialyzed into the
POAH (fig. 6).
|
|
Effects on tail-flick latency of SP microdialyzed into the PAG
after pretreatment with Nal.
Nal (10 mg/kg s.c.) alone induced a
small decrease in tail-flick latency (
7% MPA at 30 min,
5.2% MPA
at 45 min,
2.5% MPA at 60 min) (fig.
7), which was not functionally
significant (based on the standard used in our laboratory, at
least ± 20% change in MPA is considered a significant response
in the CWT). Pretreatment with Nal (10 mg/kg, s.c.) 10 min before
microdialysis of a low dose of SP (27.1 fmol/µl, by which no
significant change in tail-flick latency was produced) into the PAG
induced a similar response (
7.5% MPA at 30 min) to that seen with
Nal given alone. Pretreatment with s.c. Nal 10 min before microdialysis
of a high dose of SP (271 pmol/µl) into the PAG significantly blocked
the analgesic effect of this dose of SP.
|
Effects of SP microinjected into the PAG and POAH on Tb.
The
same doses of SP (27.1-271 pmol/µl) that produced analgesia in the
PAG failed to produce any significant change in Tb when microdialyzed
into the PAG and POAH (fig. 8).
|
| |
Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
It has been reported by our laboratory and others that SP release
could be evoked from the spinal cord by noxious cold (Tiseo et
al., 1990
) or noxious mechanical (Kuraishi et al.,
1983
, 1985
) stimuli. The increased SP level is selective for noxious
cold and mechanical stimuli as there is no such increase during noxious heat (Kuraishi et al., 1985
; Tiseo et al., 1990
).
The PAG is one of the brain regions that receives a major projection
arising from the spinal cord lamina I pain-responsive neurons (Hylden et al., 1986
). One study with retrograde labeling and
in situ hybridization histochemistry demonstrated that 61%
of the spinomesencephalic projection neurons (part of which distribute
to the PAG) in lamina I of the spinal cord express preprotachykinin
mRNA (which encodes tachykinin peptides, including SP), and this
expression is significantly increased (80%) after peripheral
inflammation, which indicates that SP plays an important role in
nociception in ascending CNS pathways (Noguchi and Ruda, 1992
). Other
studies showed that the PAG also contains extensive SP-positive nerve
terminals as well as cell bodies (Hökfelt et al.,
1977
; Moss and Basbaum 1983
) and moderate-to-high concentrations of SP
receptors (Quirion et al., 1983
). In addition, reports
indicated that tissue levels of SP in the PAG can be changed after
administration of drugs (Brodin et al.,1987
; Rosen and
Brodin, 1989). Increased SP release within the PAG during cold
stimulation may represent a nociceptive signal arising from the spinal
cord to this region. This idea is supported by the present observation
that there is an immediate increase of SP release (the first 30-min
collection) from the PAG after noxious cold water, but not 25°C
water, stimulation. On the basis of the present results, however, we
could not determine whether the increased SP in the PAG was released by
the nerve terminals projecting directly from the spinal cord or by the
local SP-containing cells within the PAG which were secondarily excited by the spinal cord ascending projection.
Our observations that pretreatment with an analgesic dose of PL017
(fig. 4, top) or Dyn (fig. 4, bottom) inhibits the cold-evoked SP
increase in this region and that this inhibition can be reversed by the
opioid receptor antagonist Nal support the hypothesis that increased SP
within the PAG carries noxious input. It has been proposed that the PAG
is one of several brain regions involved in the modulation of
nociceptive input through descending inhibitory neuronal processes that
project to the spinal cord (Basbaum and Fields, 1984
). Administration
of opioids into the PAG (Jensen and Yaksh, 1986
; Smith et
al, 1992
) or electrical stimulation of the PAG (Basbaum et
al., 1977
) produces antinociception and reduces the firing of
nociresponsive dorsal horn neurons (Bennett and Mayer, 1979
; Gebhart
and Jones, 1988
). Both mu and kappa opioid receptors exist within the PAG (Mansour et al., 1995
). Our
previous reports have shown that activation of the mu and
kappa opioid receptors in the PAG by administration of PL017
and Dyn, respectively, into this region produces dose-related analgesia
in the CWT (Xin et al., 1993
). These findings suggest that
opioid administration suppresses the neuronal activities and the
neurotransmitters which transmit pain input. A reasonable explanation
for the inhibition of SP increase after pretreatment with PL017 and Dyn
would be that increased SP release within the PAG represents the
noxious information during the cold-water stimulation. Similar results have been reported in studies by Tiseo et al. (1988
, 1990)
in which i.c.v. injection of Dyn induced analgesia in the CWT and prevented the increase of SP released from the spinal cord during noxious cold. Also, Yaksh et al. (1980)
reported a 4.9-fold
increase in SP release from the spinal cord by activating the sciatic
nerve and a naloxone-reversible inhibition of the SP release by
morphine at concentrations known to elicit analgesia. Additional
evidence for opioid action on SP levels in the PAG was reported by
Rosen and Brodin (1989). They found that morphine, given systemically in doses that are known to produce increasing degrees of analgesia (3 or 10 mg/kg s.c.), dose-dependently elevates the tissue level of SP in
the PAG of rats. The authors explained that one possible mechanism for
the increased tissue level of SP in the PAG after morphine is an
accumulation of the peptide caused by inhibition of its release. Our
present results support this suggestion in that opioids inhibited the
increased SP release evoked by noxious cold.
We further investigated the direct effect of SP within the PAG on pain
threshold by microdialyzing different doses of SP into this region. SP,
in a dose of 27.1 fmol/µl over a 30-min perfusion (which delivers a
total of 65 fmol), induced a slight but nonsignificant increase in MPA
(fig. 5). However, higher doses of SP (271 fmol/µl to 271 pmol/µl)
produced a significant increase of MPA in a dose-related manner. The
latter result is consistent with the reports from other laboratories
(Stewart et al., 1976
; Malick and Goldstein, 1978
; Mohrland
and Gebhart, 1979
; Li et al., 1991
), which suggests that
these doses of SP within the brain have analgesic effects. An analgesic
effect was also seen in an experiment conducted in mice with i.c.v.
injection of 1.25 to 5 ng SP (Frederickson et al., 1978
).
Malick and Goldstein (1978)
reported that the analgesic effect of SP
microinjected into the PAG in rats was five times as potent as morphine
on a weight basis (25 times as potent on a molar basis). Our present
results show that SP microdialyzed into the rat's PAG in a dose of 271 fmol/µl (cumulative dose, 650 fmol or 0.9 ng in the PAG, on the basis
of the recovery rate) can induce analgesia. The lowest dose of SP (27.1 fmol/µl or 65 fmol total) was in the range of the estimated peak
extracellular SP level in the PAG evoked by noxious cold (1.3 fmol/120
µl in dialysis samples or 65 fmol in the PAG, on the basis of the
recovery rate). The failure of this dose to produce a significant
analgesic effect could be explained in two ways. First, SP evoked by
the cold may only present the noxious signal but not affect the pain threshold, so that the analgesic effect of higher doses of SP may be a
pharmacological action. Second, the real amount of SP in the synapses
evoked by noxious cold may be higher than that of estimated
extracellular SP, because the latter was calculated based on the amount
of SP that escaped from the synapses and was captured by the probe.
Therefore, the lowest dose of SP microdialyzed into the PAG may not be
high enough to mimic the real action of endogenous SP in the synapses.
If this were true, SP in a dose 10 times higher than the lowest dose
may be close to the physiological range of SP acting in the synapses
during noxious cold. Because this dose of SP produced analgesia, the SP
evoked by noxious cold not only signals noxious information to the PAG
but also appears to further trigger the antinociceptive function of the
PAG.
Reports showed that some types of noxious stimuli can inhibit neuronal
and behavioral responses to noxious stimulation by activation of an
opioid-mediated mechanism which involves the PAG network (Watkins and
Mayer, 1986
; Bodnar, 1986
). These results led to a suggestion that the
endogenous pain-suppression system, which includes the descending
modulatory control pathways, can be activated by stimuli such as stress
and pain (Fields and Basbaum, 1994
). In the present experimental
procedure, we attempted to minimize the influence of stress, such as
allowing the rat to acclimate to the experimental environment, to move
freely during the experiment and by administering SP by microdialysis
without disturbing the animal and injecting opioids by microinjection at a slow speed and without animal restraint. Although handling of the
animal during the test might be stressful, we compared the
post-treatment data with the animal's own pretreatment base-line data.
In this way, any significant difference between the pre- and
post-treatment data is more likely caused by the effects of treatments,
i.e., noxious cold stimulation and the drugs. In addition, the result that no significant change in SP release before and after
the 25°C water test (in which the animal handling procedure was the
same as that used in the
10°C water test) indicates that the
significant increase of SP release during the
10°C water test is
evoked by noxious cold itself rather than handling stress. Our present
findings that noxious cold evokes SP release in the PAG and that SP
given into the PAG induces analgesia provide further evidence for the
hypothesis (Basbaum and Fields, 1984
) that "pain inhibits pain,"
i.e., pain itself is a critical factor that activates these
pathways. SP-induced analgesia is related to the endogenous opioid
system in the brain because it can be blocked by naloxone (Stewart
et al., 1976
; Malick and Goldstein, 1978
; Stewart et al., 1982
). Our preliminary data also showed that the selective mu opioid receptor antagonist CTAP (cyclic
d-phe-Cys-Tyr-d-Trp-Arg-Thr-Pen-Thr-NH2) and the
delta opioid receptor antagonist naltrindole can block or
attenuate the analgesic effect of SP administered into the PAG (Xin
et al., 1996
). Because SP itself does not bind to the opioid
receptor (Terenius, 1975
), it is generally believed that it may be
affecting opioid receptors indirectly through mediation of the release
of endogenous opioid peptides. Malick and Goldstein (1978)
suggested
that the most likely candidates among the opioid peptides would be
-endorphin (because it has been shown to exhibit a potent
long-lasting analgesic response and a rapid onset) and enkephalins
(because antibodies to met-enkephalin also antagonize SP analgesia).
Cell bodies and terminals containing these opioid peptides exist within
the PAG (Watson and Barchas, 1979
; Fallon and Leslie, 1986
; Mansour
et al., 1995
). Indeed, we observed an increase of
-endorphin release from the PAG after both SP administration into
this region and noxious cold stimulation, and this increase was
attenuated by pretreatment with a SP receptor antagonist, which
indicates involvement of this opioid peptide in SP analgesia (Xin
et al., 1994
). A possible mechanism for SP within the PAG interacting with opioid peptides and inducing analgesia has been proposed by Basbaum and Fields (1984)
. Their hypothesis is that SP,
released either from local PAG neurons activated by ascending nociceptive pathways or directly from the terminals of those pathways, acts upon local opioid peptide neurons to cause release of opioid peptides. They, in turn, activate PAG output neurons by inhibiting an
inhibitory interneuron. It should be mentioned that although SP evoked
by noxious cold could trigger the antinociceptive function of the PAG,
this function was still not strong enough to totally suppress the
tail-flick response of the rat to cold water. Hence, the weak analgesic
action of endogenous SP seems to be one of several feedback procedures
involved in the response to noxious cold.
There are reports demonstrating that various SP metabolites can
influence nociceptive responses (Larson and Sun, 1994
; Stewart et
al., 1982
). For example, the major metabolite of SP,
amino-terminal SP 1-7, is able to inhibit nociceptive behavior (Hall
and Stewart, 1983
; Larson and Sun, 1994
) and this effect can be blocked
by either Nal (Stewart et al., 1982
) or mu and
delta opioid receptor antagonists (Larson and Sun, 1993
). On
the other hand, the carboxyl terminal of SP, SP 7-11, exerts an
opposite effect (Hall and Stewart, 1983
). An in vitro study
also shows that N-terminal SP 1-7 plays a role in modifying guanine
nucleotide-modulated mu opioid receptor binding, whereas the
C-terminal SP 5-11 is without effect (Krumins et al.,
1993
). These results suggest that, unlike peripheral effects of SP,
which are mediated by receptors that recognize the C-terminal part of
the SP molecule, certain central actions of SP are mediated by the
receptors which recognize the N-terminal part of the SP molecule. It is
possible that SP may be metabolized to this active fragment before its
action at these receptors, which then produce the analgesic effect
observed in our present results. However, on the basis of our
experimental procedure, we cannot determine which fragment of SP is
involved.
The result that pretreatment with Nal blocks the analgesic effect of a
high dose of SP (fig. 7) is in agreement with earlier findings from
other laboratories (Stewart et al., 1976
; Malick and
Goldstein, 1978
) and provides evidence that exogenous SP induces analgesia through the action of the endogenous opioid system. Because
opioids generally produce an inhibitory effect on neurons whereas SP
generally produces an excitatory effect, we further investigated
whether endogenous SP itself could act differently to induce
hyperalgesia when opioid receptors were blocked by Nal. The result
showed that, at least in the PAG, endogenous SP evoked by noxious cold
or SP microdialyzed into the PAG in a low dose close to the evoked-SP
level did not cause hyperalgesia in Nal-pretreated rats (fig. 7).
Indeed, SP given intrathecally produces hyperalgesia (Lembeck et
al., 1981
; Akerman et al., 1982
; Yasphal et
al., 1982
; Dirig and Yaksh, 1996
) and SP excites those neurons in
the spinal cord responsive to noxious stimuli (Henry, 1976
). Thus it
appears that SP may play a role in sensory transmission within the
spinal cord and that this role may be related specifically to pain. SP also produces excitation of neurons in the PAG (Ogawa et
al., 1992
) when given into this region. However, the functional
consequence of the excitation produced by SP in the PAG and in the
spinal cord seems to be different because reports show that excitation of the PAG by SP or by electrical stimulation (Basbaum et
al., 1977
) induces analgesia, whereas excitation of the spinal
cord by SP causes hyperalgesia (Lembeck et al., 1981
;
Akerman et al., 1982
; Yasphal et al., 1982
; Dirig
and Yaksh, 1996
). One explanation for this difference may be the
distinct neuronal networks in the PAG and the spinal cord, because the
descending pain control system originates in the PAG and excitation of
the PAG output neuron results in the initiation of the descending
control. In addition, as mentioned above, a different distribution of
SP receptors, which recognize the N or C terminals of SP distinctively
in the PAG and the spinal cord may contribute to the different results of SP in the two regions. Therefore, it appears that SP at the PAG
level does not cause pain but activates the descending control system
through endogenous opioids to regulate pain.
SP release in the POAH did not change significantly during noxious cold
stimulation (fig. 3), although SP and its receptors have been
demonstrated in the POAH of rats (Panula et al., 1984
; Quirion et al., 1983
). Because microdialysis of SP into the
POAH does not induce analgesia (fig. 6) and there is no change of SP level after noxious cold, it indicates that this region is less important than the PAG in the integrity of pain input and
antinociception. The POAH is generally believed to be a primary site
for central control of Tb and a region which contains the highest
population of thermosensitive neurons (Boulant et al.,
1989
). Opioids can affect these neurons by either increasing or
decreasing their firing rate to alter the set point and integrate
corresponding Tb responses (Baldino et al., 1980; Lin
et al., 1984
). Opioid peptides and all three opioid
receptors exist in the POAH (Watson and Barchas, 1979
; Fallon and
Leslie, 1986
; Mansour et al., 1995
). Previous results from
our laboratory have shown that microdialysis of PL017 and Dyn into the
POAH, but not the PAG, produce hyperthermia and hypothermia,
respectively (Xin et al., 1993
). These results confirm the
hypothesis that mu and kappa opioid receptors in
this region mediate hyperthermic and hypothermic responses to opioids, respectively (Adler et al., 1988
). It is not known whether
SP within the POAH can interact with those opioid receptors. The present results demonstrate that SP microdialyzed into the POAH, in the
same doses that induce analgesia in the PAG, does not affect the Tb of
freely moving rats (fig. 8), which suggests that SP in this region is
not involved in Tb regulation and does not interact with opioid
receptors. This suggestion is supported by the reports that central
application of SP in several doses revealed no or only small and
inconsistent changes in Tb of various mammals (Clark and Lipton, 1991
)
and that SP reduced the temperature sensitivity of POAH thermosensitive
neurons (Schmid et al., 1993
).
In summary, our present results demonstrate that SP release within the
PAG, but not the POAH, can be increased after noxious cold stimulation
to the rat's tail and that pretreatment with the mu opioid
receptor agonist PL017 and the kappa opioid receptor agonist
Dyn in the PAG can prevent the SP increase. These findings suggest that
SP may transmit noxious cold information to this region and that
activation of both mu and kappa opioid receptors within this region may produce analgesia by suppressing noxious input
from ascending afferents as well as SP increase in the PAG. The results
extend our previous finding that noxious cold can induce SP increase in
the spinal cord and i.c.v. injection of Dyn can prevent the SP increase
(Tiseo et al., 1990
). In addition, SP, microdialyzed into
the PAG in amounts 10 times more than that of extracellular SP evoked
by noxious cold, produced dose-related analgesia, which indicates that
SP may not only carry noxious signals to the PAG but also trigger the
antinociceptive function of the descending pain-suppression system.
Finally, our results also demonstrate that SP does not affect Tb when
it is microdialyzed into the POAH or PAG.
| |
Acknowledgments |
|---|
We thank Dr. Nigel T. Maidment at Department of Psychiatry, UCLA Medical Center for his generous gift of dialysis membrane.
| |
Footnotes |
|---|
Accepted for publication April 7, 1997.
Received for publication September 18, 1996.
1 This work was supported by Grant DA 00376 from the National Institute on Drug Abuse.
Send reprint requests to: Dr. Li Xin, Department of Pharmacology, Temple University School of Medicine, 3420 North Broad Street, Philadelphia, PA 19140.
| |
Abbreviations |
|---|
aCSF, artificial cerebrospinal fluid; CNS, central nervous system; CWT, cold water tail-flick test; Dyn, dynorphin A1-17; i.c.v., intracerebroventricular; MPA, maximum possible analgesia; Nal, naloxone; PAG, periaqueductal gray; PL017, Tyr-Pro-N-MePhe-D-Pro-NH2; POAH, preoptic anterior hypothalamus; RIA, radioimmunoassay; SP, substance P; Tb, body temperature.
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-endorphin and morphine in the periaqueductal gray.
Neuropharmacology
31: 1137-1150, 1992[Medline].
-endorphin,
-lipotropin, and ACTH. In Mechanisms of Pain and Analgesic Compounds, ed. by R. F. Beers, Jr. and
E. G. Bassett, pp. 227-237, Raven, New York, 1979.
-endorphin (
-E) in supraspinal substance P (SP) antinociception.
Regul. Pept.
54: 329-330, 1994.